I Stream DC on Marvel

Erza, Lucy, and Juvia were stunned at what was happening in the guild. Seeing Allen selling strange potions was already absurd enough, but Natsu turning into a girl was even more shocking.

Lucy puffed her cheeks. She couldn't understand how, while she and Erza had their heads full of worries and doubts, Allen was just playing around.

Erza was also irritated; what had happened two days ago had left her nervous and unable to get him out of her mind, yet the culprit looked as fresh as a lettuce.

(Flashback)

Allen walked through the streets of Magnolia carrying Erza in his arms as she mumbled incoherently.

"I want two boys… and a girl~"

[Host, are you sure she's not awake?]

'I'll be a good guy and believe she's not awake…'

After all the emotional weight Erza had carried, Allen let her release some tension. Besides, she was a nineteen-year-old girl; there was no need to be strict with her. However, this was the second time Allen had to carry her home after drinking.

Once in Erza's room, Allen was about to leave, but Erza grabbed him. At that point, Allen suspected Erza was awake and only pretending; his suspicion solidified when he felt her trembling hand.

Allen decided not to embarrass her. He used the system to put on pajamas and slipped into bed. Erza quickly snuggled against his chest. In response to that cute action, Allen stroked her hair as the girl slowly relaxed.

'We can't keep going like this…'

Allen knew he had to give Erza an answer. However, to do that, he would have to reveal the truth about himself, and he didn't know how Erza—or even Lucy—would react. Not only that, Allen had noticed something important: the girls in this world displayed a much stronger sense of possessiveness and jealousy... than in other worlds.

As had been mentioned several times in the Chat, creating a harem in this world could be very complicated. If Allen did it wrong, he wouldn't just hurt several girls; they might walk away entirely.

[It's hard being a womanizer…]

'That's right…'

[But even so, you don't plan to give up on any of them, do you?]

'Of course not…' Allen smiled with confidence. 'I still hold the promise I made to MJ and myself.'

While Allen forged his resolve, Erza bit her lip and made an even bolder move: she used her Requip to make herself completely naked.

"…!" Allen felt the shift and looked down, freezing at the sight of the beautiful girl lying against his chest. However, he quickly accepted it, showing no hesitation or rejection as he embraced her.

Erza tensed but soon the warmth filled her chest. She had been afraid that his silence meant rejection, but it seemed her fears were unfounded. Maybe he hadn't answered her confession yet, but he had already acknowledged her feelings—she could feel it in the firmness of his embrace.

"Erza, you don't have to pretend to be asleep. I'd never deny you a hug or a kiss…"

Allen leaned in and kissed her. Erza trembled and opened her eyes. She kissed him back, and it slowly turned into something more passionate. After a few minutes, they pulled apart, and Erza looked into his eyes.

"Promise me?" With a red face, Erza asked in a low voice. "No matter who you choose, you'll never deny me this?"

"Yes, I promise…" Allen grinned shamelessly and whispered in her ear, "And what if I don't choose any girl?"

Erza immediately grew annoyed, but when she saw the piercing look in Allen's eyes, she felt those words carried a different meaning than simply rejecting them all. Erza thought of another possibility, and the moment she did, she couldn't handle the embarrassment—her brain just shut down.

[Great move. 'What if I don't choose any girl?' Anyone else would think you're rejecting them all, but anyone who knows you understands it's the complete opposite…]

Allen didn't respond but chuckled softly before hugging Erza and falling asleep.

(End of Flashback)

Erza began to get irritated, this man always did the same thing, it made her heart race and took her mind away, but he didn't show the same towards her.

'You'll see how madly I make you fall in love with me!' declared Titania proudly.

Meanwhile, the Chat, which had woken up expecting the start of another adventure, was left stunned to see Allen announcing his stance on suspicious potions like some kind of scam artist.

It was strange to see Allen like this. At the very least, it had been a long time since he started a live stream without something serious going on.

…

MJ – Woah, he went bald and then turned into a girl. That poor Natsu is going to be traumatized Haha...

Gwen – Hahaha, sorry but he asked for it!~

Felicia – If you drink a suspicious liquid without asking what it is, how can you complain? Hahaha

Tony – Wow, that was unexpected… but she's cute…

Pepper – Tony…

Angélica (Gilgamesh) – Foolishness. This king never felt that being a woman was an obstacle to ruling humanity

Rogue – …No one is saying otherwise -_-

Nikky – That potion is evil. I'm scared…

Kara – I don't get it. If you turn into a girl and you have an average face, shouldn't your female appearance also be average?

Albedo – For me, any existence outside Allen-sama is ugly, but it's true her appearance improved after becoming a woman…

Rebecca – Not only that, it seems her psyche altered with the change. This potion is insane hahaha.

Emma Frost – The funniest thing is my Allen probably made it by accident…

Orihime – I don't get it. Isn't Allen supposed to be an expert at making magic potions?

Wednesday – He has the skill. The problem is the ingredients. Fairy Tail doesn't have the same ones, and we can only find substitutes. As a result, the potions have unexpected… or completely different effects.

Rick – Magic is a type of science. Everything needs a procedure. Obviously, instead of curing hemorrhoids, you'll end up with a horn on your ass, even if you only replace one measly ingredient. *Burp*

McDragon – What a horrible image you just put in my head! But thanks… for a moment I thought Natsu was cute…

Eve – This guy…

Rangiku – Just ignore him. That's what everyone does…

Thor – Nonsense. If technically she's a girl right now, I see no problem with it…

Cate – Are you saying the god of thunder had those kinds of tastes?!

Kurumi – Ara~ Perhaps I should mention this since no one else has, but doesn't this situation seem… dangerous? You know, Allen is quite attractive to girls… though, I don't know…

The Chat froze for a moment before a third of them burst into laughter, another third turned pale, and the last group started cheering for it to happen.

When Allen saw the comments, he felt the urge to make a lot of people in the Chat experience his potions, but he decided to focus on the current problem.

....

Allen was a good alchemist. He had spent a decade in Harry Potter for a reason. However, half of his knowledge became useless upon arriving in this world. As Weddy said, the ingredients either didn't exist or didn't have the same effects. So, to make potions that he already knew he had to look for replacements.

"Natsu turned into a girl!" Happy screamed in desperation.

"What kind of ridiculousness is this?!" shouted Makarov Dreyar. However, the gaze of a dirty old man peeked through, though Mirajane's cold stare quickly made him reconsider.

"Turn me back to normal!" screamed Natsu as a feeling she had never experienced before overwhelmed her: shame.

"Allen!" Lucy ran toward him, unable to believe what she was seeing.

"Hello. Glad to see you," Allen smiled smugly as he crossed his arms.

"How can you act so calm?!" Lucy spoke in disbelief at Allen's attitude.

"Hey, Allen, don't ignore me!" Natsu crawled over to Allen and clung to his pants with teary eyes.

'How cute…' everyone thought in unison, but almost immediately they remembered that the cute girl was actually Natsu. It was like being hit with a harsh dose of reality; for the men, it was even worse—they went pale.

"..." Allen watched with amusement as everyone went crazy.

"Don't be fooled, Macao! That's a man!" shouted Wakaba.

"And what about that blush, Wakaba?!" Macao grabbed him by the collar.

Cana scoffed in disgust. "I'm sure Millgana-san and Enno-san will be thrilled to hear you drooling over Natsu."

Both shameless old men had wives, and at Cana's threat, they immediately dropped to their knees.

"We're sorry!"

"Man! Man!" Elfman slammed his head against the wall. "She's Natsu! She's a man! …Wait, isn't that a good thing?!"

Elfman's philosophy of manliness as a way of life had placed him in a dangerous situation.

"Elfman…" Mirajane looked at her brother while wiping a fake tear from her eye. "Your big sister will support you on this difficult path…"

"Damn it… Stupid Natsu. If only she were as muscular as her male version, she wouldn't look so cute," Gray muttered.

"Did you say something?" asked Reedus.

"Nothing!"

"This is diabolical…" Levy said with a dark expression, her eyes fixed on Natsu's chest. As a girl, how could she feel so inferior to a female Natsu?!

Droy and Jet, who had already recovered, instinctively took a step back, sensing the danger of being near Levy at that moment.

'Wait! What if a girl drank that potion?!' Levy froze as another possibility hit her. If Natsu, as a man, could look this cute as a woman, then if she, who was already cute, drank it… Wouldn't she become twice as beautiful?

Levy's eyes began spinning as she imagined herself as a curvy, sexy MILF. Without realizing it, she had already walked up to Allen.

"Um, do you… have more of that potion?" Levy asked shyly, though two seconds later, she realized everyone was staring at her. Her entire face turned red, and she tried to bolt from the guild.

"Levy…" Allen tried to stop her, but Jet and Droy were faster. No way would they let him steal their thunder in front of their goddess.

"Levy, you're beautiful just the way you are! It doesn't matter if you're skinny and short!" shouted Droy with sparkling eyes, putting his whole heart into his words.

Levy froze in place as…

"That's right, Levy! You're perfect even if you're flat and have no hips!" added Jet with all the gallantry he could muster.

Every girl in the guild turned an icy glare on Jet and Droy. In contrast, every guy in the guild gave them a thumbs-up—except for Allen, who facepalmed.

"You two are destined to be single forever…" Allen said. Levy turned around and walked back with a smile.

Jet and Droy smirked smugly at Allen, showing that not every girl would fall for him. But in their arrogance, they failed to notice the look of pity Allen gave them.

Levy stepped closer and closer, step by step. Jet and Droy opened their arms to receive her… but she walked right past them, stopped in front of Allen, and made him lean down so she could whisper something in his ear.

Allen nodded and pulled out two bottles from his inventory. Levy walked back to Jet and Droy, who already had a bad feeling they hadn't won her heart like they thought. Without saying a word, Levy handed each of them a potion.

Both of them went pale but didn't dare refuse; if they did, Levy would truly hate them. With a polite wave from the guys and a collective sigh from the girls, they both downed the potions—and within a second, they were bald.

"You two are idiots." Allen placed his hand on Levy's head. "You've known her for so long. You could've said Levy is kind, that she cares about others—like when she was the first to help when everyone's personalities got swapped. That even with her own flaws, she values you enough to stand on the front lines in the battle against Phantom. She's smart without being arrogant. She's naturally beautiful. She's feminine, and you'd never get bored having a conversation with her… Beyond all that, there are all kinds of body types. She's not missing anything—she's a gorgeous girl just the way she is. And as an even more personal opinion, I feel like it would be really nice to have her on my lap while I read a book… You know, she's huggable…"

....

The guild fell into complete silence. How could anyone say all that without feeling embarrassed? Just looking at Levy, who seemed ready to faint with steam pouring from her head, it was easy to understand the overwhelming shame she was feeling.

The guys had complicated looks on their faces. As men, they couldn't help but feel jealous of someone like Allen, but seeing what he was capable of, it was hard to say he didn't deserve all the attention from so many girls.

Allen noticed Levy's state and glanced at her before smiling. "One more thing: you don't need big breasts. You're already very beautiful."

Unable to take any more, Levy bolted out of the guild.

"I think I overdid it."

Erza facepalmed. "You…"

Lucy pouted so hard it could've covered all of Fiore. "Why are you always like this?!"

Juvia began muttering some kind of curse. "Why not Juvia… damn Levy… damn Levy…"

Mirajane sighed. "Another one."

Laki chuckled. "At this rate, Allen-kun will have to have a harem or he will be stabbed."

Cana frowned. "Idiot. Stop seducing the girls. Don't you know you're only going to break more hearts when you finally choose one?"

Lucy reacted to Laki and Cana's comments with a complicated look, something only Erza noticed, and raised her eyebrow.

As for Allen, he just shrugged…

"Hey, forget that! When are you gonna help me?"

Natsu crawled back to Allen's legs, clutching his pants. "She" had teary, pleading eyes. Maybe it was because the transformation had affected her heart as well, or maybe it was because she realized she couldn't force Allen to do anything and could only beg.

The men in the guild were hit with another mental hammer seeing Natsu like that—except Allen. No one wanted to accept reality.

Allen stroked his chin thoughtfully. "Even if you say that, these potions weren't something I meant to create, so I don't have a way to reverse the effects immediately."

"No way…" Natsu looked on the verge of tears. Everyone felt bad for her until her next words left them all stunned. "My muscles are gone! Igneel's gonna laugh at me!"

That's what you're worried about?! Gray rushed over to Natsu and grabbed her by the collar. "There are way more problems than that, you idiot!"

"Huh?! You wanna fight, Gray?!" Natsu grabbed his shirt too. In the end, she was still Natsu. However, Gray felt too uncomfortable looking at her and backed away.

"Let's fight another day…" Gray tried to stay calm, but seeing Allen's smug, mocking smile filled him with shame.

"They say people who fight are actually in love!"

"Shut up, Allen!"

While Gray was fuming, something happened—Natsu began turning back to normal. Gray went pale. He wasn't the only one; everyone who had considered "her" cute did too. Slowly the delicate body disappeared back to the classic pink-haired muscle boy Natsu Dragneel.

"Oh!" Natsu checked his chest. "They're gone!" Natsu also looked inside his pants and shouted, "It's back!"

Gray collapsed to his knees, clutching his head. The emotional damage was devastating. Allen, being the "kind" person he was, walked over, placed a hand on Gray's shoulder, and smiled with support and understanding.

"Don't worry. I'll give you a ten percent discount if you buy a thousand. That should be enough for you and Natsu."

No one could believe just how "kind-hearted" Allen could be. He was literally offering Gray a chance.

"Allen!!!" Gray shrieked and attacked Allen—but who was Allen?

With a single hit, Gray was embedded in the wall, completely naked with his butt on display. Gray passed out, humiliated and with yet another trauma.

Allen blinked. Many might ask what the difference was between the bastard Allen of the past and this one. The difference was simple: this Allen wasn't joking or being a bastard. If Gray liked Natsu's female version and Natsu didn't mind being a girl, who was he to stop them? So he was genuinely trying to help… or at least half of Allen thought that. The other half was just Allen being Allen.

While all that was happening, someone was slowly approaching the guild… and their attitude was anything but friendly…

====

A/N: Allen is getting nicer and nicer, just look at how he supported Gray on his new path and how he showed Jey and Droy how they should praise a girl.

More chapters on patreon: Patreon.com/_Aizen