Chapter 3: Chapter 3: Shadows of the Past
Noah's hands shook as he placed the folder back on the pew beside him. His mind was a whirlwind of questions, each one racing faster than the last. How could his father have known about whatever was hidden in this town? Why had he left such cryptic warnings? And, most pressing of all, why had no one ever told Noah the truth?
Grace watched him with an unreadable expression, as though she was letting him process everything at his own pace. But her eyes were sharp, and there was a heaviness in the way she stood, like she was carrying a weight she could no longer hide.
"You don't have to do this, Noah," she said quietly, almost as though she were trying to talk him out of it. "You've already been through so much. Some things... some things are better left buried."
Noah looked up at her, his mind made up. "I can't. I need to know the truth. I have to find out what happened to them."
Grace seemed to soften at his words, her gaze shifting to the window where the morning light now bathed the room in a golden hue. "I understand," she said, her voice barely above a whisper. "Your father was one of the best people I knew. And the things he was involved in... I don't think even he fully understood the danger."
"The danger?" Noah repeated, his heart thumping harder in his chest.
Grace nodded. "I've seen hints of it. It's a part of Willow Creek's history that most people don't know about. But your father... he was getting close to something that was never meant to be uncovered. And I think that's why they're gone."
A chill ran down Noah's spine. He stood up abruptly, pacing in front of the altar, his mind struggling to grasp what Grace was saying. "So, they were murdered? This wasn't just an accident?"
Grace didn't answer immediately, and for a moment, the silence between them felt suffocating. Finally, she spoke, her voice filled with regret. "I'm not sure. But I do believe that they were being watched. That they were too close to finding something. And maybe... maybe that's why the accident happened so suddenly. So quietly. No one ever questioned it."
Noah felt a surge of anger bubbling up inside him. For years, he'd accepted the story—his parents had been in a car crash, just like anyone else. But now, hearing Grace's words, everything felt like a lie. A carefully constructed lie meant to cover up something darker.
"This... this doesn't make sense," he muttered, more to himself than to Grace. "I don't even know where to start."
"I do," Grace said softly, her voice laced with an undeniable sadness. "I know where your father was heading. And I can show you. But be warned, Noah. Some doors, once opened, can never be closed."
Noah turned back to her, his gaze steady. "I don't care. I'm ready."
Grace hesitated, then nodded. "There's a place. A house, not far from here. It used to belong to someone your father was in contact with. Someone who might have answers."
Noah's heart skipped a beat. "Who?"
"I don't know much about him, except that he's... well, he's the reason this whole thing started," she said, glancing at the floor before meeting his eyes again. "His name was Thomas Carter. Your great-uncle."
Noah blinked, the name hitting him like a cold wave. He had no memory of any "great-uncle." There was no mention of him in his family's history. His mother and father had always kept their pasts a secret, but this was something entirely different.
"Thomas Carter?" Noah repeated, his mind racing. "I've never heard of him."
"That's not surprising," Grace said softly. "He disappeared years ago. Your parents... they never talked about him, either. But I think your father was trying to reconnect with him before the accident. I think Thomas knew something, something important."
Noah swallowed hard, a mixture of fear and curiosity settling in his gut. "Where is this house?"
Grace stood up and walked to the back of the chapel, pulling out a small, weathered map from a drawer. She unfolded it carefully and handed it to Noah. "It's located just outside of town, near the old mill. The place has been abandoned for years. But your father... he made notes. He was looking for something there."
Noah looked down at the map, his finger tracing the route Grace had indicated. His breath quickened as he felt the weight of the journey ahead of him. This wasn't just about uncovering the truth anymore. This was about finding the missing pieces of his family's story.
"You'll have to be careful," Grace warned. "There are things in this town that don't want to be found. People who will do anything to keep their secrets buried."
Noah's grip on the map tightened. He wasn't going to back down. Not now.
"I'm not scared," he said, meeting Grace's gaze one last time. "I'm going to find out what really happened."
The drive to the old mill took longer than Noah had expected. As he followed the winding road out of town, the familiar buildings of Willow Creek faded into the distance, replaced by overgrown fields and dense woods. The air grew heavier, and the quietness around him seemed oppressive. The town felt like it was slipping away behind him, and with each mile, Noah felt more and more disconnected from everything he'd known.
Eventually, he reached the mill—an old, dilapidated structure that had long since been abandoned. The once-grinding machinery had rusted and fallen apart, and the large stone building now stood as little more than a shell of its former self. The place felt eerie, as though it had been frozen in time, just waiting for someone to uncover its secrets.
Noah parked his car at the edge of the property, his heart racing. He grabbed the map and the folder of documents from the passenger seat, glancing at the large, empty structure ahead. It didn't take long for him to realize that the house Grace had mentioned was somewhere nearby—hidden in plain sight, just waiting for him to find it.
He stepped out of the car, his sneakers crunching on the gravel, and made his way toward the mill. The ground was uneven, and the air was thick with dust and decay. He felt like an intruder in this forgotten place, but the sense of urgency drove him forward.
As he got closer to the mill, Noah noticed a small, overgrown path leading behind the building, almost hidden by the thick vines and weeds. The map Grace had given him indicated that the house was somewhere along this path.
Noah hesitated, glancing over his shoulder one last time before taking the first step down the darkened trail.
He wasn't sure what he would find, but one thing was clear: he was about to uncover something that would change everything.