Chapter 10: The Rewrite Decision
The journal remained closed for three days.
Three days of uneasy stillness. Elara avoided its presence on her desk as if it were a sleeping beast. Every time she looked at it, she heard those words again: One love must be rewritten forever.
She hadn't told Rowan everything. Not yet.
Because how do you tell the person you love that in order to remember them fully… you might have to forget yourself?
On the fourth morning, Rowan sat at the edge of the bed, watching the sunrise bleed across the curtains.
"I know what you're not saying," she said softly.
Elara blinked. "What do you mean?"
"That the magic's final cost isn't just forgetting. It's sacrifice."
Elara's voice cracked. "It's not fair. It shouldn't be this way."
"But it is," Rowan said. "And we have to choose."
They sat in silence, letting the truth settle like dust.
Rowan turned to face her. "You've already lost so much. Your mother's face. Your past. You can't lose more."
Elara shook her head. "You don't understand. If I lose you again, if the magic erases you, I won't survive it."
Rowan reached for her hand. "Then we don't let it choose for us. We decide what this story becomes."
That night, they lit a circle of candles in the living room. The journal sat in the center. The pen lay across it like a dagger waiting for blood.
Chiara had warned them: once the final question was asked, the spell would answer with no mercy.
But Rowan didn't hesitate.
She stepped into the circle, picked up the pen, and wrote in clear, bold strokes:
> What if neither of us forgets?
The journal vibrated beneath her hand.
Ink spilled across the page like spilled wine, forming the words:
> Then the world must forget.
Elara gasped. "What—what does that mean?"
Rowan read aloud: "Everyone else. Our friends. Our families. Our history. If we keep each other, everything else will be wiped away. We'll exist outside the story. Ghosts."
The weight of it crushed the room.
Elara whispered, "But we'll remember each other?"
"Yes," Rowan said. "But we'll lose the world."
They had to choose.
Total memory of each other… at the cost of everything else.
Or preserve the world and risk the bond they'd only just begun to repair.
Rowan took Elara's hand. "Whatever happens, I want you with me."
Elara closed her eyes.
For the first time, she let herself believe that love didn't have to be perfect to be real.
The final decision came not in magic but in something far more human.
They decided to split the spell.
To write a new clause.
Elara took the pen and wrote:
> Let us share the burden. Let the cost divide. Let no one forget everything, but let everything change.
The journal sparked. The ink flared gold.
Then, silence.
And slowly, new entries appeared.
Images. Moments. Some altered. Some unfamiliar.
They saw themselves laughing in places they hadn't been.
Memories of love are rewritten but softened. Fragmented, yet alive.
Neither of them lost everything.
But neither would ever know what was real and what the magic had created.
They had traded certainty for survival.
And for now... that was enough.
Outside, the city lights shimmered like stars fallen to earth.
Rowan and Elara sat curled on the couch, the journal now quiet, its final spell cast.
"I don't care what was real," Rowan whispered.
Elara smiled. "Me neither."
And as they kissed, the world forgot.
But they remembered.