Letters to a Love Lost

Chapter 5: Chapter 5: The Abyss Between Us



Love doesn't always end with an explosion. Sometimes it dies quietly, with small acts of neglect that pile up until they become unbearable. With Astrid, the separation didn't come all at once; it came like a steady rain that, without us noticing, had soaked us to the bone.

There were nights when I lay beside her, but the space between us in bed felt wider than any physical distance. Astrid always slept on her side, curled up as if trying to protect herself from something, while I lay awake, staring at the ceiling, wondering how we had gotten to this point.

------------------------------

The Signs I Ignored

The signs were there, though I chose not to see them. Astrid no longer left notes on my nightstand or tried to surprise me with improvised dinners. Her gestures of love, which had once been constant, had now dwindled into an empty routine.

One day, while we were walking in the park, I brought up a plan we'd made months ago: a trip to the beach we had both dreamed of taking together.

"Maybe we should postpone it a little longer," I said, more out of habit than conviction.

She didn't respond right away. She stopped in her tracks and looked at me with a sadness that hit me like a slap.

"Do you really want to take that trip with me?"

Her question left me speechless. Of course, I wanted to—or at least that's what I kept telling myself. But something in her gaze, in the way her words hung in the air, made it clear that she wasn't asking about the trip. She was asking if I still loved her, if I still saw a future with her. And my silence spoke louder than any response.

I saw how her lips trembled slightly, as if she was holding something back, and then she looked away. In that moment, I should have said something, anything. But the weight of my own inability to face the truth kept me quiet.

------------------------------

The Breaking Point

The night everything changed started like any other. We were at home, each in our own corner of the couch. I pretended to read a book while she stared at her phone, but I could feel her unease in the air, like a storm about to break.

"We need to talk," she said suddenly, breaking the silence.

I put the book down and looked at her, trying to prepare myself for what was coming.

"I can't keep doing this," she continued, her voice trembling but firm. "I feel like I'm losing parts of myself in this relationship."

I wanted to interrupt her, to tell her she was exaggerating, that we could still fix things. But something in her eyes stopped me. Her gaze was full of tears she was holding back, but also of a determination I hadn't seen before. It was the look of someone who had fought for a long time and had finally accepted that it was a losing battle.

"I love you," she said, and those words felt like a direct blow to the chest. "But I can't keep loving you if it means losing myself."

Her hands trembled slightly as she spoke, and I could barely meet her eyes. Not because I didn't love her, but because I knew I had failed. I wanted to promise her that things would change, that I would change, but even those words felt hollow in my mind.

------------------------------

The Silence That Said Everything

When Astrid got up from the couch and began gathering her things, I did nothing to stop her. Not because I didn't want to, but because I didn't know how.

"You'll always be my Eurydice," I murmured, almost without realizing it.

She stopped in her tracks and looked at me. There was surprise in her eyes, but also a deep pain, as if those words had revealed something she had suspected all along.

"What does that mean?" she asked, her voice breaking around a lump in her throat.

"Eurydice was everything to Orpheus," I said, my voice barely a whisper. "But he lost her because he couldn't trust, because he couldn't resist the temptation to look back."

Astrid nodded slowly, as if she was finally understanding something she had been searching for all along.

"Maybe you also need to learn how to stop looking back," she replied before walking out the door.

The sound of the door closing echoed through the empty apartment. I stood there, unable to move, feeling the weight of her absence pressing down on my chest like a stone.

------------------------------

The Void She Left Behind

That night, I stayed alone in the apartment, surrounded by the things we had built together. Every corner held something that reminded me of her: the coffee mug she always used, the book she never finished reading, the scarf she had left hanging by the door.

I picked up the scarf, feeling the softness of the fabric against my fingers, as if holding it could bring back a piece of her. But it didn't. All that was left was the emptiness. It was as if a part of me had disappeared with her, leaving me incomplete, hollow.

------------------------------

The First Attempt at Redemption

Days passed before I could gather the courage to write to her. And when I finally did, every word felt insufficient:

"Astrid, I don't know how to put what I feel into words. I know I failed you, I know I hurt you, and there's no excuse for that. But I want you to know that I will always love you, even if I'm not by your side. You are, and will always be, my Eurydice."

I wrote several versions before settling on those words. I crossed out phrases, rewrote lines, but everything felt hollow compared to what I wanted to express. Finally, I sent it, knowing I might never get a response.

And I didn't. Though it hurt, I understood that I couldn't expect her to come back just because I was ready to admit my mistakes.

------------------------------

The Myth and the Reality

The myth of Orpheus and Eurydice became a refuge for me. I read it and reread it, trying to find some answer in its words. Orpheus had looked back because he couldn't bear the uncertainty, because his love for Eurydice was so great that he preferred to risk everything rather than lose her.

I had done something worse. I hadn't looked back out of love. I had let my fears and insecurities destroy something that could have been beautiful.

------------------------------

A Promise to Myself

That night, I made a promise: that I wouldn't let my story with Astrid end like Orpheus and Eurydice's. Maybe I could never win her back, but I could learn from my mistakes. I could try to be better—not just for her, but for myself.

And though I still didn't know how to start, I understood that the first step was to face my own demons. Because love, true and lasting love, doesn't come from perfection. It comes from the ability to accept our imperfections and fight for what truly matters.


Tip: You can use left, right, A and D keyboard keys to browse between chapters.