Chapter 3: Secrets and Shadows
Quinn Moriarty sat in the Hufflepuff common room, nestled beneath Hogwarts in the same corridor as the kitchens. The air carried a faint scent of warm bread and honeyed pastries, a reminder of the comfort his House was known for. Low-hanging copper pots gleamed from the ceiling, their surfaces reflecting the dancing flames from the hearth. The soft yellow glow from enchanted lanterns flickered against the cozy stone walls, casting shadows that seemed to dance between the hanging plants Professor Sprout insisted made the space feel more like home. But despite the inviting atmosphere that had drawn so many students to lounge on overstuffed armchairs and circular wooden tables, Quinn barely noticed any of it. His fingers traced the worn cover of the book he had smuggled from the Restricted Section, his mind consumed by the mysteries within. The leather binding was cracked with age, its spine bearing faded gold lettering that had nearly disappeared after centuries of handling.
The text inside was dense, filled with ancient theories on magical ailments and their supposed cures. Some sections proposed counteracting dark magic by neutralizing its lingering traces rather than reversing it outright—a concept that challenged everything modern healers at St. Mungo's practiced. The pages were filled with cramped handwriting, diagrams of wand movements, and margin notes from long-dead wizards who had tested these theories themselves. Yet, all of these theories were either unproven or long since dismissed, relegated to dusty shelves and academic footnotes. Failed experiments, lost methods—attempts that had led to nothing but disappointment and, in some cases, tragedy. But Quinn wasn't willing to accept failure as the final answer. If St. Mungo's had given up, then he would simply have to go beyond them. He needed more books and research and, most importantly, to understand why other experiments had failed in the past. Perhaps their mistakes could light his path forward.
Laughter from a nearby table pulled him from his thoughts. A few Hufflepuffs were excitedly chatting about the upcoming Triwizard Tournament, their voices carrying across the common room despite their attempts at whispered conversation. Everyone at Hogwarts knew the tournament was happening and that Durmstrang and Beauxbatons would be arriving—the news had spread through the castle like Fiendfyre, impossible to contain. What remained unknown were the champions and the dangerous tasks that lay ahead, though that didn't stop the endless speculation that filled every corner of the castle.
"I bet Krum's coming," a fifth-year whispered, barely containing their excitement. Their eyes sparkled with the possibility of seeing the famous seeker up close. "He's still at Durmstrang, isn't he? My cousin said he's taking an extended course in Advanced Defensive Magic."
"Maybe, but they've got other great wizards too," another student replied, absently stirring her hot chocolate with a cinnamon stick. "Still, imagine watching him up close. He's probably even more impressive when he's not just a dot on a Quidditch pitch."
Quinn barely listened, but something about the idea of foreign students intrigued him. Perhaps someone from Durmstrang or Beauxbatons had studied magical healing differently. Their approaches to magic often varied significantly from British methods—he'd read about that in "Modern Magical Education in Europe." If Hogwarts and St. Mungo's had no answers, then maybe the key lay elsewhere, in traditions and techniques that hadn't been stifled by British Ministry regulations.
His thoughts drifted back to the book, its pages seeming to whisper secrets in the warm common room air. He had been testing small spells between classes, careful not to push too far after his last failed attempt had left his fingers numb for three days. He needed control, not reckless ambition. Healing magic was delicate, more art than science, and if he lost focus, it could easily turn against him. The scars on his left palm—faint but still visible—served as a constant reminder of that lesson.
***
Later that night, Quinn slipped through the corridors, his mind still turning over the theories from his book. The castle felt different after hours—alive in a way it wasn't during the day, when hundreds of students filled its halls. Shadows seemed deeper, portraits whispered as he passed, and suits of armor creaked slightly, as though shifting to watch his progress. He needed more—more information, more insight, something beyond discarded theories. The Restricted Section had more texts, but breaking in again wouldn't be easy. His first attempt had been reckless, using simple unlocking charms that, in hindsight, were far too basic for the library's wards. This time, he needed a new plan, one that accounted for the magical protections he now knew existed.
As he approached the entrance to the library, he glanced around, heart pounding against his ribs. No sign of Filch's shuffling gait or Mrs. Norris's gleaming eyes, no prefects making their rounds. The corridor was as silent as a tomb. He pulled his wand out—nine inches of cedar with a unicorn hair core, chosen for its affinity with healing magic—and murmured a more advanced unlocking spell he had read about in one of his father's old books. It was a charm that worked by subtly loosening magical bindings rather than forcing them apart, like carefully untying a knot instead of cutting through it. The lock clicked softly, a sound that seemed to echo in the empty corridor, and Quinn quickly slipped inside.
Navigating the Restricted Section was a different challenge entirely. Some books whispered seductively of forbidden knowledge, others rattled in their chains like angry prisoners. The air itself felt heavy with centuries of accumulated magic. He moved cautiously, scanning the spines for anything related to dark magic healing, careful not to touch any book until he was certain it wouldn't bite or scream. He had just reached for a particularly old tome, its binding made of something that looked suspiciously like dragon hide, when a voice startled him.
"You're really bad at sneaking, you know. I could hear you breathing from three shelves away."
Quinn whipped around, his wand half-raised, a defensive spell on his lips. A Slytherin student leaned against one of the bookshelves, arms crossed, looking entirely too comfortable for someone who was also breaking rules. It was Theodore Nott again, his dark robes blending with the shadows in a way that made Quinn wonder how long he'd been watching.
The boy sighed, pushing himself off the bookshelf with casual grace. "Relax, I'm not about to go dragging you to Filch. That would be rather hypocritical, considering." He stepped forward, eyes flicking toward the book in Quinn's hands. The wandlight caught his face, revealing a knowing smirk. "Researching something again? You seem to have developed quite the appetite for restricted knowledge lately."
Quinn hesitated, studying him. Theodore Nott had a reputation for keeping to himself, avoiding the usual House politics that consumed most Slytherins. He knew Nott wouldn't tell any of the professors—the boy had his own secrets to protect—but he still felt dread about what could happen if anyone knew what he was really studying. The wizarding world had strict views about certain branches of magic, especially when it came to healing.
"Yes," Quinn finally said, tucking the book closer to his chest, its weight both comforting and condemning.
The Slytherin smirked, a knowing look in his dark eyes. "Curious enough to break into the Restricted Section two nights in a row? If I didn't know better, I'd say you were up to something more nefarious than late-night reading."
Quinn tensed slightly, but Nott just shook his head, his expression shifting to something almost like concern. "You need to be more careful. This place has more protections than you think. Madam Pince isn't just paranoid—some of these books are actually dangerous. If you get caught, don't expect me to lie for you. I've got my own research to protect."
Quinn exhaled, surprised at the lack of hostility. In fact, there was something almost like understanding in Nott's tone. "I'll keep that in mind."
Nott nodded, casting a final glance at the book before turning away, his movements as silent as a cat's. "Good luck with... whatever it is you're trying to find. And try to be a bit better at stealth—you looked ridiculous trying to sneak around. A first-year could have caught you."
Quinn wasn't sure whether to be relieved or more suspicious of this unexpected alliance, but either way, he wasn't about to waste time arguing. He gave a nod of thanks—however hesitant—and quickly slipped past the other boy, making his way out before his luck ran out. The encounter left him wondering just what Nott himself was researching in the Restricted Section, but that was a mystery for another night.
***
Back in the Hufflepuff common room, Quinn sat in a quiet corner, away from the excited chatter of his housemates who were still awake despite the late hour. The smell of cocoa and cinnamon lingered in the air, remnants of the evening's study groups. He spread his newly acquired texts across the table, flipping through the brittle pages under the dim candlelight. The books seemed to whisper to each other as he worked, their magic resonating in ways he didn't fully understand. As expected, most of them only contained failed theories—ways to counteract dark magic that had never worked, experiments that had only ended in frustration or worse. The margins were filled with notes from previous readers, some desperate, some angry, all seeking the same answers he was. But among the failures, he tried to find hints of something more. Patterns. Ideas that, if modified, might yield different results. Perhaps the previous researchers had simply given up too soon, or lacked some crucial piece of knowledge that he might discover.
He tapped his quill against the parchment, frustration gnawing at him like a persistent pest. If these wizards—some of whom had dedicated their entire lives to this research—had failed, what made him think he could succeed? But then again, wasn't that what healing was about? Finding a way forward when no one else could? After all, every breakthrough in magical history had started with someone refusing to accept the impossible.
A soft breeze stirred the pages as the common room door creaked open, admitting a group of seventh-years returning from their Astronomy practical, and Quinn instinctively closed the book. For now, he needed to keep his research quiet. The weight of his secret pressed against his chest like a physical thing, but he pushed the feeling aside. He had a long way to go, and dwelling on doubts wouldn't get him any closer to his goal. Tomorrow would bring new challenges, new theories to test, and perhaps, if he was lucky, the breakthrough he so desperately sought.
***